Sensys Blog: Loading and unloading workers are employees under the MV Act and entitled to compensation for accidents under the Employees Compensation Act, according to the Kerala High Court.
Case Summary: Abdul Razaque O.V., a loading and unloading worker for a tipper lorry owned by United India Insurance Company Limited, suffered injuries when a coconut tree being loaded fell on him. Seeking compensation, he filed an application under the Employees Compensation Act, 1923.
Insurance Dispute: The insurance company, while admitting the policy, contested liability, asserting that the policy didn’t cover risks associated with loading and unloading workers in the tipper lorry. The Employees Compensation Commissioner awarded compensation, prompting the insurance company to appeal under Section 30 of the Act.
Legal Question Raised: The appeal raised a legal question – whether loading and unloading workers of a tipper lorry owner are covered under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, specifically under clause (c) of the first proviso to Section 147(1).
Legal Arguments: The insurance company argued that the policy didn’t cover the worker’s risk, as he wasn’t the driver, conductor, or cleaner. Abdul Razaque argued that clause (c) of Section 147(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act covered loading and unloading workers.
Court’s Analysis:
1. The court considered precedents and the wording of the Motor Vehicles Act, emphasizing the importance of the loading and unloading process for the purpose of a goods carriage.
2. It rejected the insurer’s argument that the worker wasn’t traveling in the goods carriage, stating that loading and unloading are integral to a goods carriage’s purpose.
3. The court noted that the Employees Compensation Act is a welfare legislation aimed at compensating employees for work-related injuries.
Verdict: The court concluded that loading and unloading workers, including Abdul Razaque, fall under the coverage of clause (c) of the first proviso to Section 147(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act. Finding no irregularity in the Commissioner’s order, the court dismissed the appeal, affirming the entitlement of loading and unloading workers to compensation under the Employees Compensation Act.
DOWNLOAD: Loading-And-Unloading-Workers-Are-Employees-Under-MV-Act-And-Entitled-To-Compensation-For-Accidents-Under-Employees-Compensation-Act-Kerala-High-Court
Software Solutions Available on:
TDS | PAYROLL | WEB PAYROLL | WEB HRMS | XBRL | FIXED ASSET |INCOME TAX| SERVICE TAX | DIGITAL SIGNATURE | ATTENDANCE MACHINE & CCTV | DATA BACKUP SOFTWARE | PDF SIGNER
“Our Products & Services”
Sensys Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
HO: 904, 905 & 906, Corporate Annexe, Sonawala Road, Goregaon East, Mumbai- 400 063.
Call: +91 766 990 4748
Email: contact@hrmthread.com | Website: http://www.hrmthread.com
Branches: Delhi & NCR | Pune | Bangalore | Hyderabad | Ahmedabad | Chennai | Kolkata
Related Posts
TDS Rate Chart: Assessment Year: 2025-2026 Financial Year: 2024-2025.
Presenting the upcoming TDS Rate Chart for AY 2025–26, FY 2024–25! This TDS Rate Chart will help you understand the applicable TDS rate and provide a quick reference guide for Employers, Deductors...
Gujarat’s Minimum Wage Revisions for April-September 2024.
Introduction: Gujarat, one of India’s industrially progressive states, recently announced revisions to its minimum wage rates, effective from April 1st, 2024, to September 30th, 2024. These revisions...